The American economy thrives off the money left over after taxes and buying only “necessities.” Peter Singer, while wanting to provide food and medicine to third world countries of the world, will destroy our country by taking the excess money America thrives on: businesses, small and large, will collapse, and the cost of food will rise followed by a food shortage.
Taking the extra money from people in America and giving it to third world counties would be a good thing for the poverty level in other countries. In the movie Slumdog Millionaire you are able to see the poverty level in countries like India. People live in shack among shack in the ghettos where they live among garbage. Taking the excess money from America will help feed, clothe, and give shelter to all those people who can’t afford it themselves. People all give generously to organizations that help the pore, but people should not be forced to do it.
The excess money people have to spend is what keeps this country running. Our economy relies on the money people have in their pockets to buy products and keep our money flowing. All businesses rely on people spending money. If we were to just give all that money away businesses would fail and whole towns would be destroyed. My dad owns a resort on the ocean. It relies on tourism to keep the business opened. If people were forced to give all their money away, my dad and he business would become bankrupt. The whole city of Morehead and Emerald Isle would be deserted as well. If tourists spend or are forced to spend all their money on poor people in other countries, our own country will lie in ruins through the absence of the flow of money.
The United States has billions of people to feed within its boundaries. If our country decides to make all of its citizens give their excess money to other counties, our citizens would become hungry. At first our food prices in America would jump up because the world would not be used to feeding all these extra people. Feeding them would stretch the food produced today. After our food prices went up because the worlds food supply is spread so thin, people around the world, normally fed, will start going hungry. In the end, the best choice of the USA would not be to give away all our extra money, but to idolize generosity.
Peter Singer wants to do good by feeding the hungry of the world, but he really is destroying America: being forced to give away excess money will result in fewer consumers and then the destruction of small and large businesses also in a horrible food shortage. If American citizens are forced to spend their excess money on poor, third world countries, our own country will become poor and destroyed itself.
In this essay I did not concede to the prompt. I did a great deal of talking about the cons but ignored the pros a little too much. My qualification ended up being about how it was a bad idea, still, instead of a good idea. My fourth paragraph seemed a little foggy describing the relationship between the government, the food shortage, and the rest of the world. After going back I clarified my points and next time I will make sure I listen and ad by to the prompt.